Skip to main content

How objects, once trapped in ice, can become "icebreakers" themselves



In 1879, the Cincinnati publisher Charles Francis Hall told the interested reader of his monography, Narrative of the Second Arctic Expedition Made by Charles F. Hall, a most dramatic story. He heard it while searching for the third Franklin expedition in the North of the Canadian Arctic, today called Nunavut. With his Inuk translator, Taqulittuq, he interviewed Ook-bar-loo, an Aivilingmiut woman, who told him the story of Ad-lark and how she found a pocket watch:

"The body of this man was lying on one side, and was half imbedded in solid ice from head to feet. The way the chain was about the neck and running down one side of the body indicated that the watch was beneath it; and therefore, to get at the watch, she found a difficult and disagreeable task before her.[...] She was very careful not to touch any part of the body while pounding with the sharp stone. At last, after having pounded away the ice from around and under the body, her husband helped her to lift it out of its icy beds. Still she was troubled to get the watch from the frozen garments with which the body was completely dressed. Finally, the watch and key and chain were obtained entire; and the woman now keeps them very choice, in commemoration of the terrible feelings she had when getting them from the dead Kob-lu-na, whom she dug out of the ice with nothing but a heavy, sharp stone.” (For the full testimony, follow the link.)


Years later, one can just imagine how Ad-lark told Ookbarloo the story, showing her the watch. While the horror of the story unfolded, the two women must have stood closely together, maybe even touched each other and taking a close look at this very small object that once upon a time belonged to an English man.

Most remarkably, Ad-lark had heard stories about the white men and their pocket watches, even before she found the camp. On one of her journeys, she met other Netsilingmiut, who already possessed pocket watches and watch chains. So, when she found the dead man, she knew immediately what kind of object was beneath his frozen garments. Carefully not touching his face, she removed the ice and lifted the man out of his icy bed. She took the pocket watch and kept it intact. At the time of her discovery, she did not know that the man belonged to the dearly missed Franklin expedition, that had left in 1845 England in search for the North-West passage. She would learn their story later, probably in 1854 when Dr. John Rae from the Hudson Bay Company searched for Franklin and his men. Dr. John Rae brought back some pocket watch fragments, of which I examined ten in the National Maritime Museum in Greenwich.
 

Pocket Watch Fragments AAA2067 – AAA2076, National Maritime Museum, Greenwich, photographed by Julia Strobel, 5. February 2020. Published with the permission of the National Maritime Museum, Greenwich.


The mystery surrounding the Franklin expedition, as well as the objects the men carried, changed the life of the Netsilingmiut drastically. The Inuit used the materials and the objects for their own use: Knives became ulu`s, buttons were attached to outer coats and one of the most central persons in the search for Franklin`s man, Inookpooshejook, wore an officer`s hat band around his head. This very hat band was the reason why Dr. John Rae talked to him and gained so much information.

Additionally, more and more white searchers came to the Arctic, asking the Inuit for clues in the riddle, that puzzled so many Westerners, and exchanged goods for information. In Captain McClintock`s travel report, he wrote about how they saw a group of four Inuit hunters, of which one must have worn a naval button on his clothing that allowed the searchers to ask about Franklin`s men:


"We gave them to understand that we were anxious to barter with them, and very cautiously approached the real object of our visit. A naval button upon one of their dresses afforded the opportunity; it came, they said, from some white people who were starved upon an island where there are salmon (that is, in a river);"


Objects like the hat band, the buttons and the pocket watches served as conversation starters for Inuit and the white searchers alike. Their stories were told and told again and through their stories, they became intrinsically linked with the geographical place of the camps and the dead men. Visually readable for Inuit and Westerners, these objects could be understood by both. In my opinion, the connection to a specific place and readability for both groups made them so adequate as a special kind of adornment.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Pocket Watches in the Arctic -A Fashionable Item

In 1854, eleven fragments of pocket watches of the still missing Franklin expedition came back to England. On October 23rd, The Times published a report of Dr. John Rae about the ill-fated expedition. In it, he not only revealed details about the death of the men, but also mentioned items that he brought back. Part of these items were eleven pocket watch cases, that are now in the collection of the National Maritime Museum in Greenwich. It is these pocket watch fragments that particularly caught my interest. Charles Frances Hall, in search of the fate of Sir John Franklin and his men, met on his second expedition some of the same Inuit family members as Dr. Charles Rae. Thanks to Too-koo-li-too, his Inuit translator, he was able to write down the Testimony of Ook-bar-loo, a woman who knew a lot about the watches - or as Too-koo-li-too put it, about the "witches". The full testimony is at the end of this blogpost. Interestingly, Ook-bar-loo told them how and where she had s

An Inuit Ambassadress

Two members of the Schwatka expedition, the American journalist Henry Gilder and the german speaking cartographer and drawer Heinrich Klutschak, published their reports and experiences in the 1880ies. Being able to read the reports in their original language, I started to wonder about the differences. In my opinion, Gilder's interpretation is more audacious, and therefore his views and values become apparent in the text itself. As an example, I chose a  "ceremony of opening communication" , as he puts it. In an Inlet of Richardson point or Nu-oo-tar-ro, how he transcribed the Inuit name for the place, the party met some Netsilingmiut for the first time:  The ceremony of opening communication was similar to that with the Ooquee-sik-silliks a few days before, with the exception that instead of remaining in their igloos the men were drawn up in line of battle in front of them, and sent out an old woman to find out who we were and what we wanted. If our designs had be

Metallic Objects, Reflecting Light

When considering the specific mode of adaptation the Inuit used regarding my pocket watch fragments, I wondered what kind of general observations I could make. In my previous blog post,  The Afterlife of the Pocket Watches , I already mentioned that wearing these played a crucial role in adapting some objects. In-nook-poo-the-jook, who will become one of the most crucial witnesses for Western explorers searching for Franklin and his men, wore an  officer's hatband  around his head. Thanks to Logan Zachary, there is a high-resolution photograph of this hat band on his  blog . However, he was not the only one who wore an object, formerly belonging to one of Franklin's men. Also, Captain McClintock writes in his  travel report  about four Inuit hunters, of which one must have worn a naval button on his clothing. Additionally, "my" pocket watch fragments were worn around  the neck . In these cases, the Inuit found the objects in a camp, where some party members died. Logi